Is Online Therapy Right for You? What to Know Before Your First Session
With clinical insights from Jay Gottschalk, NP, NMOD and Medication Management Provider at Advanced Psychiatry

Online therapy has gone from a niche option to one of the most common ways people access mental health care. But for all its growth, plenty still wonder whether it’s as effective as sitting across from someone in an office, and whether it’s the right fit for what they’re going through.
We sat down with Jay Gottschalk, NP, at Advanced Psychiatry to talk through what online therapy actually is, who tends to benefit most from it, when in-person care might be the better option, and what he wishes more people understood before their first virtual session.
One of the Biggest Advantages of Virtual Therapy: Access
For many people, the biggest obstacle standing between them and mental health care isn’t stigma or cost. It’s simply distance. That's a barrier Gottschalk understands firsthand. “I grew up in a rural community where online treatment didn't exist and the nearest therapist was almost three hours away. That distance kept me from getting help,” he notes. “For other people, the barrier is leaving their homes at all. Online therapy lets millions of people get care without the travel and time that stood in my way.”
This barrier is still very real for a lot of the country. Rural areas have far fewer mental health providers per capita than urban ones. More, according to the Rural Health Information Hub, 40% of people in small or isolated rural communities live at least 30 minutes from the nearest mental health facility, compared to fewer than 10% of people in urban areas. Telehealth helps close that gap, with the same source reporting that 43% of rural adults who received behavioral health treatment in the past year used telehealth at least once a month.
Access isn’t just about distance, either. Gottschalk explains, “It also widens your options. Finding a provider who is a good fit for you is one of the most important parts of quality mental health care. Online, you aren’t limited to whoever happens to practice nearby. You can look across your state, and beyond it if the provider is licensed where you live.”
Who Tends to Thrive with Online Therapy
Whether access is limited or you simply prefer virtual visits, it’s important to know that online therapy isn’t always the best option for every person. Those who tend to do well with virtual therapy are people who can set aside distractions and create a real pocket of focus for their sessions, even if that space isn’t glamorous. “Ideally, there’s a place at home or at work where you can give the therapist your full attention. Sometimes that means going out to the garage or sitting in your car. Putting your phone on Do Not Disturb helps too, so notifications don’t pull you away from the work of therapy.”
What Kinds of Therapy Work Well on a Screen?
Similarly, just as there are types of people who do best with virtual therapy, there are also specific types of therapy that translate well to online care. A common assumption is that certain types of therapeutic work simply don’t translate to video. Gottschalk pushes back on that, arguing that many types of therapy work well remotely. These include:
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT): CBT focuses on changing negative thought patterns and behaviors. Because it uses structured worksheets and specific goals, it translates easily to video calls.
Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT): DBT teaches emotional regulation, mindfulness, and distress tolerance. Practicing and reflecting on these skills can be done naturally in remote therapy sessions.
Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT): ACT uses mindfulness and inner exploration to accept difficult emotions. Therapists can easily share screens or guide exercises virtually.
Psychodynamic Therapy: This approach explores past experiences and unconscious patterns. Virtual therapy still allows for an emotional connection and deep conversation.
What matters most, Gottschalk says, regardless of the therapeutic approach, is helping his patients create a space where they can stay focused. “At the first visit, I get a sense of how someone is engaging from wherever they’ve chosen to be. If that setting is making it hard to engage, we work on it together. That might mean finding a different room or changing the settings on their phone so it stops interrupting.”
Building Trust Through a Screen
If you feel virtual therapy is a good fit for your needs and the approaches you prefer, you may still be wondering, how do you build a real therapeutic relationship with someone you may never meet face to face?
For Gottschalk, it comes down to two core principles: radical acceptance and compassion. “That means accepting the person as they are, and believing that throughout their mental health journey, they’re doing the best they can in that moment with the tools they have.”
Know the Logistics Before Your First Online Session
You know what kind of therapy works well for virtual care and whether online counseling may be right for you. But there are more, equally important factors:
Finding the Right Provider
Before trying online therapy for the first time, Gottschalk recommends thinking about both who you’re working with and how you’ll show up to the session. “Look for a provider who fundamentally wants to find a path that helps you get well, and who understands they may not be the best fit for you,” he advises. “A good therapist will help you make meaningful progress and, if needed, help you bridge to someone who is a better fit.”
Eliminating Distractions
“Before your first session, find the spot you’ll use and put your phone on Do Not Disturb. Headphones can help with privacy.”
Understanding Licenses
Gottschalk also flags a detail many people don’t think to ask about: “It’s worth confirming that the provider is licensed in the state where you’ll be during your sessions. Licensing is based on where the client is located, not where the therapist is, and it’s a fair question to ask.” This is a real regulatory requirement, not just a best practice.
According to the Center for Connected Health Policy, telehealth is generally considered to take place at the patient’s physical location, meaning a provider typically needs to be licensed in whatever state the patient is sitting in during the session, not just the state where the provider’s practice is based.
The Surprising Downside of Virtual Care: Staring at Yourself
Even if you’re used to virtual meetings, either as a patient or an experienced provider, and you understand the logistics behind online counseling, many still find themselves caught off guard by something unexpected: their own face.
For Gottschalk, it was something most people don’t think twice about. “Something I didn’t expect is how much staring at our own faces for hours on end can wear on self-esteem. That started some years ago, when so much of life moved onto video calls. My advice to therapists and patients alike is to turn off self-view so you can focus on the people you’re talking with instead of on how you look.”
This lines up with published research. A Stanford study on video call fatigue found that prolonged self-focused attention during video calls (essentially, staring at your own image) is a major contributor to exhaustion, producing what researchers called “mirror anxiety.” Their recommendation matches Gottschalk’s exactly: turn off self-view.
When In-Person Therapy May Be the Better Choice
Online therapy isn’t the right fit for everyone, and Gottschalk is direct about when he’d steer someone toward an office visit instead: “If someone doesn’t feel they have a safe place to do therapy from home, coming into an office can make the work easier. In-person visits also help people who spend most of their day at home. Leaving the house can be a welcome break from the stressors there, and it removes the distractions that come with being at home or at work.”
The Bottom Line
If there’s one thing Gottschalk wants people to walk away understanding, it’s this: one bad session, or one mismatched therapist, doesn’t mean online therapy itself failed you.
“My biggest concern is that people will treat one session, or one therapist, as what therapy is always like. Therapy is provided by people with very different training, including counselors, marriage and family therapists, nurse practitioners, physician associates, psychiatrists, psychologists, and social workers. They use different approaches, like acceptance and commitment therapy, cognitive behavioral therapy, dialectical behavior therapy, internal family systems, and solution-focused therapy. And each of them brings their own personality.”
That variety is good news for patients. “With that many combinations, it’s very likely there’s someone out there who is a good fit for you. It may take trying a few therapists to find them.”
Finding the Right Fit, In Person or Online
Whether online therapy is the right choice comes down to your circumstances, your comfort level, and, as Gottschalk emphasizes, finding a provider who’s genuinely invested in your progress, not just filling an appointment slot. For many people, the flexibility and access of virtual care make it possible to get help they otherwise wouldn’t. For others, an in-person setting provides the structure and safety they need to do the work.
If you’re considering online therapy or medication management, the team at Advanced Psychiatry is here to help you figure out which approach, and which provider, is the right fit for you.
-----
Resources
Rural Health Information Hub
Center for Connected Health Policy
Stanford News



